BAYESIAN TRAGEDY: An Evil Revenge Plot or Divine Justice???

6

Aug 28/2024:  It certainly isn’t every day that a 183-foot superyacht sinks in a matter of minutes, while at anchor, with 12 crew and 10 guests aboard. So it’s entirely understandable that the very abrupt sinking of Bayesian, an enormous Perini Navi sloop, at around 4am on August 19 off Porticello, Sicily, resulting in the deaths of a famous British tech tycoon and six others, has sparked a firestorm of media interest. Most major news organizations have been releasing stories on the tragedy on a daily basis for more than a week.

The latest news is that Italian authorities have again questioned the yacht’s skipper, James Cutfield, a 51-year-old Kiwi, and are officially pondering whether to bring manslaughter charges against him. A perfectly understandable development. Any time a ship goes down and all but one member of the crew survives and a majority of the passengers don’t, the crew will have a lot of ‘splaining to do, as Ricky Ricardo might put it.

James Cutfield, skipper of Bayesian. The only member of the crew who didn’t survive was the cook, Recaldo Thomas

Also, while early speculation had it that it was a waterspout that sank the big boat and that the mast (the longest aluminum spar in the world) may have snapped in two, the latest intel is that it was likely a fierce microburst that did the deed and the mast is intact.

Of course, there’s also been a lot of discussion about how such a large vessel could be so catastrophically and suddenly overwhelmed in a squall, no matter how violent, while at anchor. Giovanni Costantino, CEO of the Italian Sea Group, which owns Perini Navi, has asserted the boat was bomb-proof and the crew was grossly negligent, in that they should have secured all apertures, got underway, and roused the guests as soon as they understood that heavy weather was imminent. Which is, of course, patently absurd, as any superyacht crew that routinely hoisted anchor and woke up their guests in the middle of the night any time a squall might come along would soon be looking for other work.

More sapient souls have focused on the questions of down-flooding, watertight bulkheads, and Bayesian’s stability. For an interesting discussion on those topics, I commend you to Canadian yacht designer Tad Roberts, who has been pondering the yacht’s fate on his Facebook page in a series of posts that have elicited some interesting comments. It’s also worth checking out these comments from a former skipper of Bayesian.

Tad’s speculative image of Bayesian heeled over to 70 degrees to starboard, close to its angle of vanishing stability. The boat was found underwater lying at 90 degrees on its starboard side. All but one of the bodies in the vessel were found in one cabin on the port side

The last image of Bayesian afloat, with her mast lights visible in CCTV footage from on shore moments before she disappeared

I happened to be in Ireland when Bayesian went down, with my wife, a corporate mergers-and-acquisitions attorney, and her brother, a corporate finance guy trained in accounting. What they immediately focused on was that the boat’s now-dead owner, Mike Lynch, the so-called “Bill Gates of the UK,” had just been acquitted of fraud and conspiracy in a high-profile criminal trial in the United States. Indeed, the whole purpose of the ill-fated cruise was to celebrate Lynch’s acquittal, and the other victims included his defense attorney, Chris Morvillo, and a big hot-shot banker, Jonathan Bloomer, who testified on his behalf as a character witness. This, coupled with the fact that Lynch’s co-defendant at trial, Stephen Chamberlain, who was also acquitted, had been killed in a hit-and-run accident while jogging in Britain just two days earlier, seemed awfully suspicious to them.

Mike Lynch and his 18-year-old daughter, Hannah, who was also lost when Bayesian went down. Hers was the last body recovered

Long story short, the relevant facts as to the criminal trial are that Lynch sold his British software company, Autonomy, to the U.S. computer hardware firm Hewlett-Packard for something like $11 billion in October 2011. After the deal closed, HP discovered Autonomy had been cooking their books and so had to write off something like $8 billion in losses. Ouch! The result was a whole bunch of legal actions, both civil and criminal, on both sides of the Atlantic. Though Chamberlain, Autonomy’s VP of finance, and Lynch were both acquitted in their criminal trial just last month, Autonomy’s chief financial officer, Sushovan Hussain, was in fact convicted of fraud in an earlier U.S. trial. All in all, not a good look.

Being Irish, my wife and brother-in-law often have a dark, fatalistic view of things and found it hard to believe that the deaths of both Lynch and Chamberlain, occurring almost simultaneously, could be merely coincidental. I tried my best to reason with them. Certainly Lynch and Chamberlain’s big nemesis, Hewlett-Packard, might conceivably organize a hit-and-run accident in the UK. But deliberately arranging for a big superyacht to sink in a sudden squall on the coast of Sicily would be nigh on impossible. Besides, HP did win a civil trial against Lynch in Britain, and after damages are established, he may end up owing them as much as $4 billion. Much better, therefore, to wait until after he pays up before you try to bump him off.

The hit-and-run accident and the weather that sank the boat, I told them, had to have been an act of God, an obvious case of Divine Justice. And there’s really no need to speculate right now on exactly how Bayesian went down. With so many survivors, 15 out of the 22 souls onboard, and the vessel intact (albeit under 165 feet of water) the truth will be known in good time.

I will note, however, as a general matter, summer weather in the Mediterranean, a very popular cruising ground, has become increasingly violent as the sea grows warmer. Surface temps this summer have been up to 86 degrees Fahrenheit! Not long before the Bayesian incident, there was also a very violent squall in Spain’s Balearic islands that succeeded in driving many boats and at least one superyacht ashore.

Weather in the Med has always been tricky, but—insurers take note—this is something else entirely.

Meanwhile, I do think we should tip our hats to the 20 divers who worked so hard to retrieve bodies from the wreck of Bayesian. Over the course of 123 dives between them, they spent over 4,400 minutes in the water.

They did a fantastic job!

For more examples of large vessels sunk very quickly by sudden bursts of strong weather check these previous posts on the school ships Concordia and Albatros.

Related Posts

3 Responses
  1. Nick

    I’ve been waiting for you take on the issue and checked the site every day:-)
    I’m surprised that you think that cautious crew would be fired the day after they disturbed the sleep of the owner due to weather conditions
    As far as I understand the weather was not just a “regular august storm in the Mediterranean” and they knew it in advance.
    If what you say on crew-owner relationship is a reality, I hope the Bayessian will serve a good lesson to the rest of crews and owners.
    Especially I’m surprised that they didn’t go to some survival trip or ocean crossing where you may hit a storm underway and there is no much to do.
    They were on a pleasure sail near big island with ports that can accomodate such vessel, why taking risk in the beginning?
    I’m sure the captain would now prefer being fired for being too cautious than being questioned for the manslaughter

    1. Charles Doane

      Hi Nick! It very obviously was not just a regular August storm. But lots of times you don’t know that in advance. I have no idea what was forecast and what the crew knew about the forecast. Everything I’ve seen thus far is pretty speculative on that front. I do know that truly dynamic weather like this downburst or waterspout whatever it was that took out this boat is hard to predict. You can know a squall is coming, but you can never really know what is in it until it is on you. Most of the time they are perfectly manageable. Getting your guests up and ready to abandon ship every time one comes along is just not realistic. We will know for sure what happened in this case eventually. And I’m sure it will teach us some useful lessons.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe

Subscribe

Please enable the javascript to submit this form

Facebook Pagelike Widget

Archives

Google Ads