THE INVASION OF ANGUILLA: A Comedy of Errors, Caribbean Style

0
Anguilla beach

I first learned of the British invasion of Anguilla, which took place in March 1969, while studying Don Street’s Transatlantic Crossing Guide several years ago. In his classic tome (which I can still recommend as a great general reference if you are cruising the islands of the North Atlantic), Don mentions the event in passing and cites two books treating it. One, The Mouse That Roared, he claims is a fictionalized account of the invasion; the other, Under An English Heaven, he cites as a factual account.

The Mouse That Roared, by Leonard Wibberley, which I read as a boy, in fact was published in 1955, 14 years before the invasion of Anguilla took place. It tells the tale of a fictional European micro-nation, the Duchy of Grand Fenwick, that declares war on the United States, hoping to garner a bonanza of foreign aid after its inevitable defeat. Instead, through a series of improbable events, Grand Fenwick ends up in control of a U.S. secret weapon, the Q-Bomb, and in effect conquers the world. Though the book has nothing to do with Anguilla, its comic spirit does mirror that of the real-life improbable events that led Britain to invade Anguilla after the tiny island rebelled against independence from the British crown.

Nope, that’s not a typo. They rebelled against independence.

I finally got around to reading the second of Don’s recommended books this past winter and it was, as advertised, directly on point. Appropriately, it was written by a prolific comic crime novelist, Donald E. Westlake, and though the narrative is certainly tongue-in-cheek and also very entertaining, it is scrupulously researched and near as I can tell is still the most detailed account of both the invasion and the long series of events leading up to it.

The problem in a nutshell was that the British, as far back as 1822, had always insisted on administering its possession of Anguilla through the colonial government it  established on St. Kitts, in spite of the fact that Anguilla would much rather have been ruled directly by Britain. And when Britain granted independence to its West Indian colonies in the 1960s, it again rather negligently lumped Anguilla in together with St. Kitts (and also Nevis). It didn’t help matters that the newly independent nation was ruled by one Robert Bradshaw, an ex-sugar worker and labor leader from St. Kitts, who openly despised Anguillans.

“I will not rest,” Bradshaw once declared of Anguilla, “until I have reduced that place to a desert.”

Though the Anguillans strived mightily to alert the British to the fact that they could not abide being ruled from St. Kitts, their pleas fell on deaf ears. A few months after the associated state of St. Kitts-Nevis-Anguilla became officially independent in February 1967, the Anguillans effectively seceded by chasing 17 police officers from St. Kitts off their island. The rebel flag they hoisted after committing this heinous act of insurrection was the British Union Jack.

Police station

Flag raised after the Anguillans liberated their police station

There followed many months of comic opera. Various outsiders tried to exploit Anguilla’s new ambiguous status for their own ends. Robert Bradshaw made noises about invading Anguilla. The Anguillans formed a provisional government and launched an abortive raid on St. Kitts, hoping to kidnap Bradshaw and hold him hostage until Great Britain recognized their secession from St. Kitts. Bradshaw meanwhile insisted that Anguilla had been taken over by the American Mafia.

The British finally sent an incompetent diplomat, William Whitlock, to Anguilla to try to sort things out. Whitlock was greeted by the island’s provisional leader, Ronald Webster, and a crowd of people who were waving pro-British posters and singing God Save the Queen. Whitlock in response totally dissed Webster and the Anguillans. After his people tossed out leaflets to the crowd detailing the British proposals for ending the crisis–“as a farmer might throw corn to fowl” was how the local newspaper described it–Whitlock refused to ride in the motorcade Webster had organized to receive him. He also refused to have lunch with Webster. Afterwards, the young toughs who had styled themselves as Anguilla’s Defense Force, over whom Webster had no effective control, intimidated Whitlock and his group by brandishing the few firearms they possessed, whereupon the so-called diplomat fled the island.

Bradshaw and Webster

Mortal enemies: Robert Bradshaw, leader of St. Kitts (left), and Ronald Webster, provisional leader of Anguilla (right)

William Whitlock

William Whitlock, the man who precipitated the invasion

Believing the Queen’s anointed representative had been fired upon and forcibly ejected from Anguilla, the British immediately laid plans to invade. The invasion, code-named Operation Sheepskin, was a badly kept secret, so the Anguillans had plenty of time to prepare. These preparations consisted of a complete demilitarization, in which all guns on the island were taken over to St. Martin and buried. The invasion force, consisting of two British frigates, 135 paratroopers, and 40 Scotland Yard police officers, was greeted by a horde of foreign journalists and met no resistance from the local populace.

Goat patrol

Elements of Britain’s Red Devil parachute battalion on goat patrol

Swimming cops

London police take a swim after helping to invade the island

The world’s press was derisive in its commentary. Time magazine described the invasion as “Britain’s Bay of Piglets.” The British Spectator termed it “The War of Whitlock’s Ear.” Newsweek’s headline was “The Lion That Meowed” (which may explain how Don Street got confused about The Mouse That Roared). Mr. Whitlock lost his job and never again worked for the British government. But in the end–here comes the happy ending–Anguilla finally got what it wanted all along: direct rule from Great Britain.

It was, I believe, the only time in history that a country has launched an insurrection in order to become a proper colony.

This is only a capsule description of the whole sordid affair, with all sorts of juicy and hilarious details left out. To enjoy the full course of absurdity you really need to digest the book. It’s the perfect thing to read while lolling about on a boat in the Caribbean. The book is out of print, alas, but you can always find a copy at my favorite used-book website: abebooks.com

Under An English Heaven, by Donald E. Westlake
Simon and Schuster, 1972 (278 pp.)

6 Responses
  1. PC

    I am not an Anguillian, but my family and I lived there for four and a half delightful years. I knew many of the people involved in the revolution and was regailed with their stories repeatedly. Their joy and pride in telling and retelling the stories enhanced the enjoyment of hearing the stories. So much of how things transpired is reflective of the most delightful and disarming Anguillian sense of humor.

  2. Willa

    Your synopsis is historically incorrect in a major detail. What was granted in the 1960s was NOT independence. It was internal self government as an associated state of Great Britain. St. Kitts and Nevis became an independent state in 1983. Anguilla is still a British Overseas Territory with internal self government. And it’s not all as hilarious as it may seem. My uncle was a young soldier at Camp Springfield on 10 June 1967 when the Anguillans invaded St. Kitts with the help of persons in opposition to Bradshaw’s government. He could have died that night. They came with guns not comic books.

  3. Montague Kobbé

    Nice to see this recycled! If you liked Westlake’s book, Charles, you should take a look at my novel The Night of the Rambler (http://montaguekobbe.com/index.php/books/the-night-of-the-rambler/), which deals with the Anguilla Revolution and links it to similar events in the region. And just a little clarification: the purpose of the revolution was not to renew ties with Britain, it was to achieve separation from St Kitts at all cost, even if it meant going back into the colonial fold.

  4. Julian Tullett

    JT
    I was part of the Royal Engineers contingent in 1969 where we built the school (gone) primarily with asbestos panels and roofing but what did we know then, built a jetty (gone except for one pile), extended roads and extended the airport runway plus numerous smaller things. Lived in tents for 6-months into the hurricane season and interacted with many residents who were great. The beaches were great in 1969 and unspoiled but went back a few years ago and what a transformation into a fabulous exclusive resort destination. Now living in Canada.

  5. Bootneck

    What I always find disconcerting is the details of who was there, not one account I have read shows that there was a Royal Marine detachment from HMS Rhyl there.I know this because I was there. There were 23 of us, 100 Paras, and a few days later the Metropolitan Police turned up. I’d love to know where this horde of foreign journalists were, I don’t remember seeing one, perhaps they were waiting for us in a local bar!

  6. John (jake) spriggs..surveyor.

    JT
    I was part of the Royal Engineers contingent in 1969 where we built the school (gone) primarily with asbestos panels and roofing but what did we know then, built a jetty (gone except for one pile), extended roads and extended the airport runway plus numerous smaller things. Lived in tents for 6-months into the hurricane season and interacted with many residents who were great. The beaches were great in 1969 and unspoiled but went back a few years ago and what a transformation into a fabulous exclusive resort destination. Now living in Canada.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe

Please enable the javascript to submit this form

Facebook Pagelike Widget

Google Ads